Xboxist

Snake is an enhanced clone while Sam Fisher is just a normal human so...

ill tell you what happens. the two find themselves in a stalemate and end up blowing each other up with a giant bomb. then Kojima pops out of a hole and comes up with some ridiculous explanation for how Snake survives the explosion. so Snake wins... somehow.

I'm voting for Solid Snake here.

Snake calls in Raiden.

I know how this ends, my 93.5 years, half retarded, pot-smoking, whiskey drinking granny shows up and beats the crap out of em (drunken master style ofc) and then she pees all over em

Obviously, the two should reluctantly work together to achieve their goal.

It's the greatest mismatched buddy-cop videogame of all time.

Isn't Snake super old now, his genes were programmed not to last as long as everyone else's. So yeah Fisher would probably own him, but if this were MGS1 era then Fisher would be completely destroyed. I mean come on, Solid Snake usually shows up with NOTHING, he's badass enough to procure everything on sight. Fisher has nightvision goggles, knives, and all kind of gadgets and addons for his guns.

Then, batman slowly and quietly drops down (fresh off selling 1 million copies of AA) and completes and inverted takedown on Fisher. Snake, confused, runs over to investigate while batman grapples to the next gargoyle. One batarang later and both Snake and Fisher are out cold. A little explosive gel for the WMD and game over.

SNAKE would win obviously.

I like them both but I prefer Sam on Snake .

@ WWII: Snake is not a clone and he is not "enhanced" at all...

But he's still better than Fisher. I like both of them though.

Sam Fisher gets shotgunned and dies, while Snake shits on his face

3 arguments

Snake would win, in a firefight he has better acurracy considering in all splinter cells game you are overpenalized for moving while you shoot meanwhile since mgs2 there is always a boss fight that requires you to do it.

Snake has more experience in stealth out the window boss fights while sam can only fight from the shadows. Besides he can get tips from the codec like telling him to make jokes which make sam lose his temper and giving him the advantage :P

If they flow into fisticuffs snake would theoretically win as CQC is supposed to be composed of the best of each martial disciplines including Krav Maga, besides cqc includes the use of knife and handgun which outplays sams one or the other style. And as far as i am concerned sam never outfought anyone with krav maga.

well.. i like snake but..... I vote for sam fisher

I vote for Solid Snake

snake should use cqc 2 whoop his shyt

I'm voting for the Legendary Solid Snake.

A wild snorlax appears.

Hey. Its me Sam Fisher. Snake and I had a talk and we both came to a conclusion that he would destroy me.

S.Fisher

um i vote for snake really lol, that dude fought agaisnt a dude in a tank with grenades lol, dude with miniguns mind control, metal gear, vamp that bitch survived 3 times or so lol, his brothers they kick ass, a ninja, a sniper expert, 4 lunatics with advance high tech lol, infiltrated a place with loads of guards, while sam fisher needs darkness on his side lol, all MGS villians will say , um who is this fool? lol

Snake would win obviously...

My vote for sam fisher !!

I prefer snake. Also wouldn't his octocamo stay on. I thought the battery only effected the ipod and Metal Gear MK2. Also I want the MGMK2 to be in the story :( I think snake would have already won though, because he could have shot sam by now, before his camo stopped working.

Solid snake wins

I'm voting for fisher, snake has nothing left he can't even roll without hurting his back i mean honestly! make sam do his nose punch uppercut thing and win. BUllPUPS RULE! (sam fishers gun)

snake hands down. sam fisher is a little girl next to snake.

sam

I bet you if snake appears in Metal Gear Rising, hes gonna be in a wheel chair like zero was on the mgs4, and he still whoop sam's as$

Snake is a Clone and he is enhanced the world war 2 snake is naked snake the original Snake aka Big Boss thats who they cloned to make snake if you play the games you'll see that there actually is more then just one

@Shawn
have you played the games? Obviously not so please don't tell people that hey are wrong even though you don't understand the mgs universe.
(Snake ftw. he doesn't rely on gadgets and gizmo's and can do ever thing he does in a tux. plus Sam doesn't have a infinate ammo headband lol)

They both fight for a while and eventually both lose there weapons. Then they fight hand to hand and Snake wins.... obviously.

In my opinion its really close. both are very similar but have their own styles, Snake has been through more, people with weird abilities taken out mech suits ect, But sam hes a normal guy, taken out god knows how many enemies, but same goes for snake, soooo snake close but snake ftw

solid snake hands down. best hand to hand

i go for solid snake.
it would be a close match, but snake will defeat sam fisher

Excerpt from wikipedia

Advanced cellular degeneration caused by a purposeful flaw in the cloning process used to create him has aged him prematurely.

end

@ SHAWN
lemme guess, you skipped every cutscene because you wanted to snpie the next guard in his jewels huh.

Solid Snake

If this were a stealth fight, Fisher would win it without question. Why? When was the last time Snake HONESTLY used stealth? Standing around a corner, then running out is barely stealth, and invisiblity suits that aren't really invisible? Half the time, Fisher is above you, or right in front of you, and you don't know it. Snake carries 98 weapons and fights every boss out in the open. He is barely stealth.

But if it's a firefight, Fisher is fucked. As mentioned, Snake carries a fucking armoury. Pistols, grenades, Two, count 'em TWO types of rocket launcher. The man is not stoppable with bullets, so Fisher would lose that one.

But a hand to hand fight? That would be interesting. Look at Convictions recent trailer to see the kind of environmental self defence Fisher knows. Every manoeuvre he uses is genuinely applicable self defence. All I've seen from Snake is the three hit combo for basically every game. Plus, Sam fishers knife kills are epic. I'd give hand to hand to Fisher.

So, 2/3 for Fisher, I say he wins.

sanke would win he would whip sam's ass

Snake is more than a spy he destroys giant walking nucular tanks how is this even a contest ROFL

I vote snake because truthfully the way snake was spotted by Sam Fisher he could not only just do a MGS roll out the way then Octocamo but, he could just turn around and MK.2 Fisher and then blow fishers head off.

i vote sam, if snake and sam had no equipment on them and had to get into a building unspotted, sam would do it, he hardly ever uses any gagets and in the new game he has hardly any

Snake all the way. He may be old, but that suit enhances his strength, so hand-to-hand is an easy win. He's significantly more accurate with a gun, and has experience fighting enemies Sam can't even dream of.

As soon as Snake looks up, Snap! Crackle! Pop!

Snake>Sam FACT

SAm Fisher would win if he was not in a firefight have you seen the videos of his new game Conviction the guy is actaully a ninja and Snake isnt really stealthy at all. Yes, Metal Gear started and made the first stealth game but Splinter Cell actually defines what a stealth game should actually be like. So Sam Fisher would win in a steath and close combat fight but gun fight it would be close but Sam would loose

I'd say snake wins. For various reasons:

For one snakes resourcefulness has been proven time and time again. It is his ability to adapt to conditions that makes him great. This ability has helped him defeat people who could hardly be called human. People far more sinister then Sam Fisher...

Fisher simply has a lot of experience fighting lowly guards and the occasional experienced fighter.

What snake lacks in technology he makes up for with his general senses and experience. They are far more in tune then fisher as fisher depends on his technology constantly.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=knuzobEX4hw

Sam fisher is no doubt a great soldier and a top notch spy. But compared to snake, he is as green as the lights on his night vision goggles.

Snake has fought all his life, since the day of his birth. He knows of nothing else but combat and the ways of a true warrior. He has knowledge of every aspect of warfare and has always willingly put his life on the line without question, or in that case, without anyone asking him of it. Because he doesn't require orders from anybody to know what needs to be done, he just does it.

Countless times, Snake has Gone against the worst off odds with .0000000000001% chance of survival and has come out on top. Bloodied, Bruised, Battered and scared. But never once has he been broken or beaten.

And if it came down to it, Snake would destroy Sam Fisher. The last thing Fisher would see is his ass where his nuts should be.

Snake is a super soldier, so there is no way Fisher can win against Snake. REX and numerous unmanned metal gear can't even take down Solid Snake. Even the Beauty and the Beast corps were no match for him.

Snake wins. He's defeated so many weird bosses that Sam will seem like a "generic" boss. Not that he'll be easy, not by a long shot, just that he's not as weird as some of the ones Snake has previously defeated. Or, maybe the fact that he's so not weird will win the battle for him. hahha

dude snake would kick the shit out of sam fisher lets
see his saved the world muliple times from evil people and his brother and all sams done is get kicked out of nsa after going rouge becuase of duaghter issues
if that was snake in that situation snake would forget he had a daughter becuase in kojimas world it probabley wasnt his any ways and snake would just go about his mission and save the world again

Sam Fisher for sure!! he is way more deadly than Snake!!

Ok first of all the person didn't say if it is the young snake, or the old snake. For all we know this could be a scenario where both are at a younger age.... I'd say snake, Sam just isn't use to the paranormal circumstances in which snake was usaully in.

And plus Sam is more of a boyscout in my perspective as to being the ultimate agent trained in possible combat scenario possible.

Snake, he's a supersoldier xD.

And Sam Fisher would start crying when he hears Snake's smooth voice xD

Snake would win for multiple reasons. Snake has been in combat longer than Sam Fisher, he has more experience and has survived and weathered a hell of a lot more than Sam has.

@Waltrus:

I must ask if it is you who have actually played the MGS games. Because at the end of MGS4:GOTP, it is explained [In the long, drawn out Kojima cutscene fashion) That there were 3 clones of the "Legendary Mercenary" Big Boss, Solid Snake, Liquid Snake, and Solidus. Although Snake actually inhereted the recessive genes of Big Boss, he is the best out of all of them because of his Will, his tenacity, and his experience in all forms of combat on the battlefield, as well as being a master of CQC, a Kojima variant to Mixed Martial Arts, and the ability to use any firearm he finds. Which, he does, since he picks up all his equipment on the field.

Summary: Snake wins. Sam just doesn't cut it.

Solid Snake would win.

sam fisher should win ....snake is a clone but he is not....and he is like a ghost and better in QQC ...

Sam Fisher wins!!

snake hides in the box and sam just passes by. snake gets out and slid sam's throat

Lol of course sam fisher is going to win. Just look at the URL it's by microsoft fan boys

snake wins

Right i have played both Splinter Cell with Sam Fisher and Metal Gear Solid with solid snake. So my opinion is not biased.

I will split it in to 3 catogories. Shoot out, stealth out, fight out!

Shoot out:
In terms of accuracy they are both good, and up until mgs4 i would have put my money on Sam Fisher, however with the new behind the camera reticle aim that Snake now possesses, similar to splinter cell, i would say Snake wins that. On top of this Fisher perhaps has 3 guns per mission, Snake has atleast 70 in mgs4, so in terms of running out, i doubt it. Snake takes my vote.
Stealt Out:
I understand Fisher is more better with using shadows to his advantage, but is there always shadows, noooooooo. So technically if it were day time wouldn't he be kinda useless :S. Snake however has stealth camo and octocamo, both work day and night and make him completely invisible. Snakes wins
Fight out:
Now i understand that people know of the Krav Maga that Fisher possesses, and that you all say Snake has a three hit attack, time for you to wake up from mgs1 and play number 4, he has a rally of CQC attacks that mix Judo with MMA and also some karate and believe it or not KRAV MAGA. So technically he has the advantage. Snake wins

Snake 3/3
Fisher 0/3

BTW all this nonsense slowing Snake down cos of his age is rubbish, he still completed a mission Fisher never could. :)

first of all, Fisher wouldn't get that close just to chat, if Fisher gets near someone it is because he is almost delivering a deadly blow. Fisher has all gadgets he needs, with his cameras and googles there is no chance to Snake to get near Fishers... Fisher is a walking trap. I like but Snake, but c'mon, he would win just inside a ring with CQC vs CQC if they had the same age, the old Snake has no chance vs Fisher.

who of the two hides inside carton boxes?

pretty obvious who would win.

Sam Fisher

its obvious snake will win he is surerior than sam in many ways for e.g snake stealth tecniques r better than sam his weaponary skills r also better than him n without weapons he is still a good fighter

Well, if you're putting it into a firefight then Snake should win. But if you're comparing Stealth, then I'd say Sam wins. He is more skillful in it than Snake. Read the books!

I like them both. It depends on the scene for me. At night, I take Sam Fisher. Daytime, give a gun to snake and hes on like donkey kong. Stealth goes to Fisher Fight goes to Snake.

ive owned and played mgs4 and played the demo of conviction its easy to say sam wins cause snake is gotten verry old

Ok, now before I go off on a rant lets get this over with first. I LOVE SPLINTER CELL. The first one, Pandora Tomorrow, and Choas Theory (lets forget the other two were made...) were amazingly fun games. And compared to the metal gear solid series the stealth was more realistic. (some thing fake though, like being a shadow 2 inches from a guy and him not seeing you)

BUT I LOVE METAL GEAR SOLID EVEN MORE! The metal gear series is my favorite game series of all Time, MGS1 being my favorite (not that piece of crap Twin Snakes). But yeah.

Honestly, considering what ive just said. Ok, so in MGS snake has godlike aim, in SC, you have to wait for like 3 seconds after pointing at an object for sam to straighten his aim so he will actually hit it. Snake can just turn around and HS anyone. ok, so gun fighting snake wins.

Fist to fist, well if hes fighting MGS1-MGS2 snake, then snake wins, hes just as agile as sam and has CQC. if its MGS4 snake then sam is just triply screwed. Snake has a muscle enhancing sneaking suit. Hes like 3 times stronger then sam with that beast. He will come up grab his hand and twist and turn and rip it right off.
So Snake wins all scenarios.

(Also, the MGS series does have great stealth, if you play the game RIGHT)

Sam fisher would woop snakes assssss he a silent killing machine and snake is an old washed up roach Sam would knock da shyt out of snake!!!!!!!!!!!!!

dude when are you going to finish the story!

sam fisher is more stealth that snake, he can be killing any koment anytime and snake, never know what happen.

Dude Sam fisher is the first splinter cell and splinter cell's are ... well invisible til they break your neck and snakes camo wont work sam has electro-magnetic vision goggles and thermal i dont think snake will see him coming. also if you count the latest splinter cell- conviction, sam can kill enemies within seconds.

let me put it this way as a fan of both game series.

Solid Snake:
Clone of the infamous Foxhound Leader, and all around professional spy and special ops agent, Big Boss(A.K.A Naked Snake).

like his 'father', he has many a skill in CQC, which is many different Martial Arts put into one Mixed move, which, unlike the game makes it seem, is hard to even learn such things all together.

He starts off everything with just a pistol and a knife, like his father again, or nothing at all, like MGS1 suggests, and procures every weapon on the field of battle, to which he has extensively trained with each and every weapon, learned how to use each weapon, and how to disarm an opponent using said weapon.

In terms of stealth, Snake again has Fisher beat, for Fisher,he needs shadows, Snake, in MGS1 and 2, uses his surrounding, his environment, he adapts to everything, even shadows, if there are any,which for him,there are hardly any, but with MGS4, he has Octocamo which allows him to blend into a wall, or floor, and otherwise,even more effective when not in the light, because he cannot cast a shadow.

Sam Fisher:
Expertly trained Soldier, now here's where everyone doesn't understand Sam's potential, yes he indeed seems less of a spy when compared to Snake,but you give little credit to his knowledge and skill.

Sam went through many of the more trying area's of the US Military, he even served in Iraq, and went against unheard of numbers with a team of 4 men,one of which being his best and long time friend, and partner.

Sam Fisher is a man of great tactical knowledge and skill, his equipment is beautiful, and he knows his weapons like he knows the contours of a woman's body, and, like Snake, has deadly skill and knowledge with each.

Now, to pit the two against each other like this is quite the battle, how Sam is being portrayed in this seems more of a green thumb newbie, and how Snake seems to be portrayed is indeed along the lines of the true Snake, but even Sam Fisher gets serious when it comes to his mission.

But from my own experience and Opinion, the Skill in Weaponry, Fighting, and Stealth has to go to Snake.

Why?
Because although Sam is indeed the fearsome agent of death and stealth, Snake has had much more experience and training, and he knows when Anger isn't needed in times of fighting or thought,he knows how to hone himself to the occasion and setting to be able to take down his enemy, Sam Fisher has been recently portrayed as a more childish and anger prone man(((SPOILER))but any man who has lost his daughter,and found out his best friend is a liar and traitor would be((SPOILER))Snake has had his fair share of mentally trying times, but he has gone man to man and man to machine against Metal Gear Rex, Metal Gear Ray, and many different form's of utterly impossible to kill Psycho-kinetic humanoids and Nuclear-armed Mech's, while Sam Fisher has only had to deal with normal, over-paid, over-priced merc's, terrorists, and world-domination psycho's, how can human beings with loads of money and guns and nuclear arms compare to actually facing the Nuclear weapon on two feet towering around 200 feet above you or so?(sorry if that's a bit exaggerated) I'm sorry, but compared to Solid Snake, Sam Fisher just doesn't make the cut in terms of knowledge,tactical advantage,stealth,skill,and battle experience, Snake is the obvious winner, because with how Sam is acting now, it would be the same as if fighting Meryl(without mind control) in MGS1, Sam is just too green and too emotion prone.

Sam Fisher would win, Snake is a Crappy old Prune When Sam is in action its lighting Snake is Slow and Bulky.